Evaluating Quality in Information

Quality in information comprises several characteristics, including accuracy, scope of coverage, objectivity, timeliness, authority, and verifiability. Take time to recognize it. It could keep you well-informed, prevent you from relying on illicitly edited material, save you money, or preserve your health. It could even save a life.

Accuracy: factually irrefutable and complete information. Tip: Is there a second reliable source that gives the same information? Is it a peer-reviewed source. Does the publisher use editors and fact checkers?
Scope of Coverage: the extent to which the source explores a topic. Scope of coverage may include a period of time, a geographic region, various aspects of a topic, etc. Tip: Does the source offer information about its scope?
Objectivity: minimum bias with respect to interpretation or analysis of facts. Tip: Is the source trying to persuade you? Who sponsors or publishes the information? What can you discover about their intentions? 
Timeliness: information that is current at the time of publication. Tip: Does the source provide a date for this specific Web page or entry, as opposed to a general site revision date?
Authority: a reliable source of information. Tip: Can you determine the name of the author and publisher? Is the author a recognized expert on the topic? What is the publisher's reputation?
Verifiability: confirmation of the facts or information with a second reliable source. Tip: Does the material cite to its sources of information?

Close this window

COPYRIGHT: © 2001 Ballard Spahr Andrews & Ingersoll, LLP all rights reserved.

This chart appears in Teaching Internet Research Skills, a teaching Web of The Virtual Chase at URL http://www.virtualchase.com/researchskills/quality3.html.